[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Issue: OUTPUT-STREAM-P-EXAMPLE
- To: CL-CLEANUP@SAIL.STANFORD.EDU
- Subject: Issue: OUTPUT-STREAM-P-EXAMPLE
- From: ROSENKING@A.ISI.EDU
- Date: 26 Oct 1988 16:48-EDT
- Sender: ROSENKING@A.ISI.EDU
â??
Status: Initial Proposal
Issue: OUTPUT-STREAM-P-EXAMPLE
References: OUTPUT-STREAM-P (CLtL, page 332, ANSI Draft, page 6-37)
Category: CLARIFICATION
Edit History: 26 -Oct-88, Version 1 by Rosenking
Related Issues:
Problem Description:
When evaluating the example from the ANSI draft, shown below,
(output-stream-p (make-concatenated-stream))
the value returned is either NIL, in MAC and VAX implementations, or T in
Symbolics implementations.
Proposal:
Specify the correct value to be returned and verify that other implementations
do not make the same mistake. (Note: I sent a bug report to Symbolics.)
Rationale:
For validity and conformance.
Current Practice:
Adoption Cost:
Benefits:
Conversion Cost:
Aesthetics:
Discussion: