[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Issue: LOAD-TIME-EVAL (Version 6)

Well, let me say up front that this description is absolutely unacceptable
to me because of the verbiage about destructive modification.

Also, I am concerned about how the "right thing" can be done with the
env argument in the case of

   (DEFUN FOO (X) '(X #,(SQRT 3))))

In a file compiler, the #, must read in a way that is acceptable to the
compiler's runtime environment (compile to core) and the compiler's file
environment (compile to file). And this decision must be made at

If instead you wrote:

   (DEFUN FOO (X) #,`(X ,(SQRT 3))))

and #, expanded into a LOAD-TIME-VALUE expression, then the compile to
core operation could treat the LOAD-TIME-VALUE special form in one way
and the file compiler could treat the LOAD-TIME-VALUE special form
another way and things would work nicely as a natural result of the
accessibility of the lexical environment from the special form.