[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Slot-boundp vs slot access

>Why is slot-boundp slower than slot accessors (almost twice as slow from my
>tests)? I would have thought that an unbound slot is in fact bound to a special
>value (a cons for instance).
>     Daniel.

Slot accessors (as defined by DEFCLASS) are MCL's optimized form of
slot access. All other slot access (including SLOT-BOUNDP) in MCL uses
linear search to find the slot. The implementation is as fast as it can
be (a two-instruction assembly language loop), but it's still linear search.
Slot accessors hash the class wrapper to an index for the slot: a faster

An unbound slot is indeed marked by a special value. This makes SLOT-BOUNDP
run at about the same speed as SLOT-VALUE.