Status

[Masinter.pa@Xerox.COM]

Please pay special attention to the issues marked *.  I believe these
are the ones where last-minute wording changes might have invalidated
consensus. I hope I was adequately cautious in my mailing to X3J13.

I am going to be on vacation starting next Wednesday until right before
the X3J13 meeting.

David Moon has kindly offered this group a meeting room at Symbolics on
Monday. I suggest we start at 10:00, with a break for lunch, and plan on
ending around 4:00 PM.  

We have a request from Skona Brittain (an X3J13 member from
Microcomputer Systems Consultants in Santa Barbara) to join the cleanup
committee. Unfortunately, she does not have mail access. While it seems
unlikely that anyone not on the net could usefully participate, I am
reluctant to turn down enthusiastic volunteers.


! 

In this file: EB = Benson, GLS = Guy Steele,
PC = Pavel Curtis, KMP = Kent Pitman,  SEF = Scott Fahlman,
LMM= Larry Masinter 

[name/initials] position => person had position on ballot.
[all] position => everyone who voted on this issue voted this way
position on ballot.

Withdraw = "Place on hold pending resolution of comments already
received."

! released
* nearly ready for release

! Proposal format (Version 11)
	Released 11-Jun-87 13:07:17

 * ADJUST-ARRAY-DISPLACEMENT (Version 3 / 5-jun-87)
	(Standardize interaction of adjust-array and displacement)
	Comments & edits after ballot.
	Not ready for release

ADJUST-ARRAY-NOT-ADJUSTABLE (version 1/22-apr-87)
	(Extend adjust-array so its OK on non-adjustable arrays.)
	comments from Moon, JonL, SEF against current form
	[EB, PC, SEF] Withdraw
	Not ready for release

! AREF-1D (Version 5)
	(Add a new function for accessing arrays with row-major-index)
	[all] Version 2 with name => ROW-MAJOR-AREF
	Version 5 released 11-Jun-87 13:07:50
	

* ASSOC-RASSOC-IF-KEY (Version 1/22-Apr-87)
	(Extend ASSOC-IF, etc.  to allow :KEY)
	[EB, GLS, KMP] Release as is
	[LMM] ASSOC-IF has CAR for KEY?
	Reply?

COMPILER-WARNING-BREAK (Version 2/7-Apr-87)
	Questions on interaction with condition proposal.
	Is this an environment issue?
	Not released.

! COMPILER-WARNING-STREAM (Version 6/ 5-Jun-87)
	(Compiler warnings are printed on *ERROR-OUTPUT*)
	(Version 4, submittted by SEF was withdrawn --
	consider DRIBBLE as a separate issue) 
	Version 3 released.
	Version 6 released 11-Jun-87 13:15:29

! DEFVAR-INITIALIZATION (Version 4)
	((DEFVAR var) doesn't initialize)
	Version 3 Released
	Version 4 released 11-Jun-87 13:30:32

! DEFVAR-INIT-TIME (Version 2/29-May-87)
	(DEFVAR initializes when evaluated, not later.)
	Version 2 released 11-Jun-87 13:30:22
	
DO-SYMBOLS-DUPLICATES (Version 2/29-May-87)
	(can DO-SYMBOLS see the same symbol twice?)
	[EB, GK] DO-SYMBOLS:ALLOWED
	[PC, Moon, LMM] something like :ADD-KEYWORD
	not ready for release
	
ENVIRONMENT-ARGUMENTS (Version 1)
	Separated into other proposals.
	Withdrawn.

FILE-WRITE-DATE-IF-NOT-EXISTS 
	(What does FILE-WRITE-DATE do if no such file?)
	Not yet submitted.

! FLET-IMPLICIT-BLOCK (Version 6/ 5-Jun-87)
	(do FLETs have implicit named blocks around them?)
	Released 11-Jun-87 13:36:10

! FORMAT-ATSIGN-COLON (Version 4/5-jun-87)
	Version 3 released.
	Version 4 released 11-Jun-87 13:44:27.

* FORMAT-COMMA-INTERVAL (Version 1/10 June)
	Ready for release?

FORMAT-NEGATIVE-PARAMETERS
	Not yet submitted; mail 19-May by KMP

! FORMAT-OP-C (Version 5/ 11-Jun-87 14:00:19)
	(What does ~C do?)
	Release to X3J13

FUNCTION-TYPE (Version 4/ 29-May-87)
	(Change definition of FUNCTIONP, function type ...)
	 [EB, GLS, PC] Release as is [GK] Stronger [Moon] OK after comments
	addressed 
	[KMP] break in two, so I could
       support the half I like and only grump about the parts I don't
	want stronger warning
	[SEF] 2-option, 3-option version
	Not ready for release

GC-MESSAGES (version 1)
	(Control over unsolicited GC messages in typescript)
	Submitted by Pitman 23-Apr-87
	In discussion: merge with other controls for
	unsolicited messages?


! GET-SETF-METHOD-ENVIRONMENT (Version 4, 11-Jun-87)
	(Environment argument for GET-SETF-METHOD)
	[EB, GLS, PC, Moon, SEF] Release as is 
	[GK] Ballot says comments follow, but no comments?
	[KMP] NIL as null lexical environment
	Released 11-Jun-87 14:18


* IF-BODY (Version 5, 29 Apr 87)
	(extend IF to implicit progn if more than one ELSE form?)
	General agreement to recommend against.
	While EB, PC, Moon voted to wait for a version that KMP and SEF
		agreed was fair, SEF said 5 was fair enough.
	LMM will reformat

IGNORE-ERRORS (Version 4, 29-May-87)
	[EB, LMM, PC, Moon] Wait for error proposal
	[GLS, KMP, SEF] Release as is (but remove "Larry wonders ...") 
	KMP will release as report from cleanup + error committee

! IMPORT-SETF-SYMBOL-PACKAGE (Version 4/ 29-May-87)
	Version 3 Released
	Version 5 released 11-Jun-87 14:48:33

* KEYWORD-ARGUMENT-NAME-PACKAGE (Version 6/11 Jun)
	[EB, GLS, PC, Moon] Release as is (some typos) [SEF] Comments
	Ready for release?

LOAD-TIME-EVAL (Version 1, 6 Jun 87)
	Moon may rewrite? (Please)
	Not ready for release

MACRO-FUNCTION-ENVIRONMENT 
	Not yet submitted (From ENVIRONMENT-ARGUMENTS)

! PATHNAME-STREAM (Version 2)
	[EB, GK, PC, Moon, SEF] Release as is
	Released 11-Jun-87 15:03:54

PATHNAME-SYMBOL (Version 2)
	[GLS, PC, Moon, KMP, SEF] Release as is
	[eb] against, want minority view (needs formatting)
	Moon " cover every argument that is called pathname,
         filename, file, or new-name
         and leave the rest of the ambiguities for another proposal?"
	Not ready for release

PEEK-CHAR-READ-CHAR-ECHO (Version 1)
	Agreed to be controversial
	[EB, GLS, PC, KMP] Withdraw from consideration, await new proposal
	Not ready for release

! PRINC-CHARACTER (Version 3)
	Released 11-Jun-87 15:35:59

PROCLAIM-LEXICAL  (Version 1)
	In discussion
	Some progress
	Need volunteer to merge comments into new version
	Not ready for release

PROMPT-FOR (Version 1)
	Agreed to be controversial
	[EB, PC, Moon, SEF] Withdraw
	Not ready for release


PUSH-EVALUATION-ORDER
	(What order does (PUSH (A) (CAR (B))) evaluate (A) and (B)?)
	[PC, SEF] (PUSH FIRST SECOND)
	Not yet submitted. 

REQUIRED-KEYWORD-ARGUMENTS
	("A hole in Common Lisp: RPG/....")
	Not yet submitted

REMF-DESTURCTION-UNSPECIFIED (Version 1)
	Submitted by DLA
	Discussion?
	Not ready for release.

SEQUENCE-FUNCTIONS-EXCLUDE-ARRAYS (Version 2)
	(FIND, SUBSTITUTE etc work on multi-dimensional arrays?)
	Version 2 by KMP 28 Apr 87 
	In discussion, no clear consensus
	[EB] Unchanged [PC, KMP, SEF] Undecided
	Not ready for release

SHARPSIGN-BACKSLASH-BITS
	(What does C-META-H-X mean?)
	Mild for this proposal, but preference for
	removing FONT and BITS attribute 
	 [EB] Release as is
          [pc, KMP] no, remove bits & font
             want fuller character proposal
          not ready for release

SHARPSIGN-PLUS-MINUS-NUMBER
	Discussed, without general agreement.
	[RPG against, GLS for, SEF reluctant, etc.]
         not ready for release


SHARPSIGN-PLUS-MINUS-PACKAGE
	Seems like general agreement for :KEYWORD.
	Need to remove other options from proposal
         not ready for release


SPECIAL-FORM-SHADOW
	Is it OK to shadow a special form with FLET, LABELS?
	Not yet submitted
	(From ENVIRONMENT-ARGUMENTS)

TAILP-NIL
	Not yet submitted.
	Needs volunteer to format.
	Notes from Moon

UNWIND-PROTECT-CLEANUP-NON-LOCAL-EXIT (Version 1)
	In discussion
	Need volunteer to summarize issues