cleanup ballot

[goldman@vaxa.isi.edu]

Ballot submitted by Neil Goldman (Goldman@vaxa.isi.edu)
Organization:  USC/Information Sciences Institute
Status:  Interested Party -- not official position of organization


ARGUMENTS-UNDERSPECIFIED:SPECIFY
	Version 4, 21-Sep-88, Mailed 4 Dec 88
YES

ARRAY-TYPE-ELEMENT-TYPE-SEMANTICS:UNIFY-UPGRADING
	Version 9, 31-Oct-88, Mailed 5 Dec 88
YES

CLOSED-STREAM-OPERATIONS:ALLOW-INQUIRY
	Version 5,  5-Dec-88, Mailed 5 Dec 88
YES

CONTAGION-ON-NUMERICAL-COMPARISONS:TRANSITIVE
	Version 1, 14-Sep-88, Mailed 6 Oct 88
YES

DECLARATION-SCOPE:NO-HOISTING
YES
DECLARATION-SCOPE:LIMITED-HOISTING
NO
	Version 4, 15-Nov-88, Mailed 9-Dec-88

DECLARE-FUNCTION-AMBIGUITY:DELETE-FTYPE-ABBREVIATION
	Version 4,  5-Dec-88, Mailed  5-Dec-88
YES

DECLARE-TYPE-FREE:ALLOW
	Version 8, 7-Dec-88, Mailed 9-Dec-88
YES

DECODE-UNIVERSAL-TIME-DAYLIGHT:LIKE-ENCODE
	Version 2, 30-Sep-88, Mailed 6 Oct 88
YES

DEFPACKAGE:ADDITION
	Version 7, 2-Nov-88, Mailed 5 Dec 88
YES

DEFSTRUCT-CONSTRUCTOR-KEY-MIXTURE:ALLOW-KEY
	Version 2, 21-Sep-88, Mailed 6 Oct 88
YES

DEFSTRUCT-PRINT-FUNCTION-INHERITANCE:YES
	Version 3, 7 Dec 88, Mailed 12-Dec-88
NO

DEFSTRUCT-SLOTS-CONSTRAINTS-NAME:DUPLICATES-ERROR
	Version 4, 31-Oct-88, Mailed 12-Dec-88
NO

DESCRIBE-INTERACTIVE:EXPLICITLY-VAGUE 
YES
DESCRIBE-INTERACTIVE:NO
NO
	Version 4, 15-Nov-88	, Mailed 7-Dec-88

DOTTED-MACRO-FORMS:ALLOW
	Version 3, 15-Nov-88, Mailed 7-Dec-88
YES

EQUAL-STRUCTURE:STATUS-QUO
	Version 5, 1-Oct-88, Mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

EXIT-EXTENT:MINIMAL
NO
EXIT-EXTENT:MEDIUM
YES
	Version 5, 12-Dec-88, Mailed 12-Dec-88

EXPT-RATIO:P.211
	Version 3, 31-Oct-88, Mailed 7 Dec 88
ABSTAIN

FIXNUM-NON-PORTABLE:TIGHTEN-DEFINITION
NO
FIXNUM-NON-PORTABLE:TIGHTEN-FIXNUM-TOSS-BIGNUM
YES
	Version 4, 7-Dec-88, Mailed 12-Dec-88

FORMAT-E-EXPONENT-SIGN:FORCE-SIGN
	Version 2, 2 Oct 88, Mailed 6 Oct 88
ABSTAIN

FORMAT-PRETTY-PRINT:YES
	Version 7, 15 Dec 88, Mailed 7 Dec 88
YES

FUNCTION-COMPOSITION:NEW-FUNCTIONS
NO
FUNCTION-COMPOSITION:COMPLEMENT-AND-ALWAYS
NO
	Version 4, 12 Dec 88, Mailed 12 Dec 88

FUNCTION-DEFINITION:FUNCTION-SOURCE
	Version 2, 09-Dec-88	, Mailed 9 Dec 88
NO

FUNCTION-TYPE-ARGUMENT-TYPE-SEMANTICS:RESTRICTIVE
	Version 3, 7-Dec-88, Mailed  12-Dec-88
YES

FUNCTION-TYPE-REST-LIST-ELEMENT:USE-ACTUAL-ARGUMENT-TYPE
	Version 5, 14-Nov-88	, Mailed 8-Dec-88
NO

GET-MACRO-CHARACTER-READTABLE:NIL-STANDARD
	Version 2, 8 Dec 88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

HASH-TABLE-PACKAGE-GENERATORS:ADD-WITH-WRAPPER
	Version 7, 8-Dec-88, Mailed 9-Dec-88
YES

HASH-TABLE-STABILITY:KEY-TRANSFORM-RESTRICTIONS
	Version 1, 11-Nov-88	, Mailed 12 Dec 88
NO

HASH-TABLE-TESTS:ADD-EQUALP
	Version 2, 8-Dec-88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

IN-PACKAGE-FUNCTIONALITY:SELECT-ONLY
	Version 4, 12-Dec-88, Mailed 12-Dec-88
YES

LAMBDA-FORM:NEW-MACRO
	Version 4, 22-Nov-88, Mailed 8-Dec-88
NO

LCM-NO-ARGUMENTS:1
	Version 1, 17 Oct 88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

LISP-SYMBOL-REDEFINITION:DISALLOW
	Version 5, 22-Nov-88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

MAKE-PACKAGE-USE-DEFAULT:IMPLEMENTATION-DEPENDENT
	Version 2, 8 Oct 88, Mailed 12-Dec-88
NO

MAPPING-DESTRUCTIVE-INTERACTION:EXPLICITLY-VAGUE
	Version 2, 09-Jun-88, Mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

NTH-VALUE:ADD
	Version 4, 8-Dec-88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

PACKAGE-CLUTTER:REDUCE
	Version 6, 12-Dec-88, Mailed 12-Dec-881
YES

PACKAGE-DELETION:NEW-FUNCTION
	Version 5, 21 nov 88, Mailed 8 Dec 88
YES

PATHNAME-TYPE-UNSPECIFIC:NEW-TOKEN
	Version 1 27-Jun-88, Mailed 7 Oct 88
YES

PEEK-CHAR-READ-CHAR-ECHO:FIRST-READ-CHAR
	Version 3, 8-Oct-88, Mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

PRINT-CIRCLE-STRUCTURE:USER-FUNCTIONS-WORK
	Version 3, 20 Sep 88, Mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

PROCLAIM-LEXICAL:LG
	Version 9, 8-Dec-88, Mailed 12-Dec-88
YES

RANGE-OF-COUNT-KEYWORD:NIL-OR-INTEGER
	Version 3, 9-Oct-88, Mailed 14-Oct-88
YES

RANGE-OF-START-AND-END-PARAMETERS:INTEGER-AND-INTEGER-NIL
	Version 1, 14-Sep-88, Mailed 7 Oct 88
YES

REQUIRE-PATHNAME-DEFAULTS:ELIMINATE
	Version 6, 9 Dec 88, mailed 09 Dec 88
NO

REST-LIST-ALLOCATION:NEWLY-ALLOCATED
NO
REST-LIST-ALLOCATION:MAY-SHARE
YES
REST-LIST-ALLOCATION:MUST-SHARE
	Version 3, 12-Dec-88, mailed 12-Dec-88
NO

RETURN-VALUES-UNSPECIFIED:SPECIFY
	Version 6,  9 Dec 88 mailed  9-Dec-88
YES

ROOM-DEFAULT-ARGUMENT:NEW-VALUE
	Version 1 12-Sep-88 mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

[The following are mutually exclusive]
SETF-FUNCTION-VS-MACRO:SETF-FUNCTIONS
	Version 3, 4-Nov-87, mailed Nov 87
YES

SETF-PLACES:ADD-SETF-FUNCTIONS
	Version 1, 11-Nov-88, mailed 9-Dec-88
NO

SETF-SUB-METHODS:DELAYED-ACCESS-STORES
	Version 5, 12-Feb-88 mailed 8 Oct 88
YES

STANDARD-INPUT-INITIAL-BINDING:DEFINED-CONTRACTS
	Version 8, 8 Jul 88, Mailed 7 Oct 88
YES

STEP-ENVIRONMENT:CURRENT
	Version 3, 20-Jun-88, mailed  7 Oct 88
YES

STREAM-ACCESS:ADD-TYPES-PREDICATES-ACCESSORS
NO
STREAM-ACCESS:ADD-TYPES-ACCESSORS
YES
STREAM-ACCESS:ADD-PREDICATES-ACCESSORS
NO
	version 2, 30-Nov-88 mailed  9 Dec 88
	(expect amendment T => "true")


STREAM-INFO:ONE-DIMENSIONAL-FUNCTIONS
	Version 6, 30-Nov-88, mailed 9 dec 88
	expect amendment:
		LINE-WIDTH   ==> STREAM-LINE-WIDTH
		LINE-POSITION ==> STREAM-LINE-POSITION
		PRINTED-WIDTH ==> STREAM-STRING-WIDTH
YES

SUBTYPEP-TOO-VAGUE:CLARIFY
	Version 4,  7-Oct-88, mailed 7 Oct 88 
YES

SYMBOL-MACROLET-DECLARE:ALLOW
	Version 2,  9-Dec-88, mailed 9 Dec 88
YES

SYMBOL-MACROLET-SEMANTICS:SPECIAL-FORM
	Version 5, 30-Nov-88, mailed 9 Dec 88
YES

TAGBODY-CONTENTS:FORBID-EXTENSION
	Version 5, 9-Dec-88 mailed 9 Dec 88
ABSTAIN

TAILP-NIL:T
	Version 5, 9-Dec-88, mailed 12-Dec-88
ABSTAIN

TEST-NOT-IF-NOT:FLUSH-ALL
NO
TEST-NOT-IF-NOT:FLUSH-TEST-NOT
YES
	Version 3, 1 Dec 88 mailed 9 dec 

TYPE-OF-UNDERCONSTRAINED:ADD-CONSTRAINTS
	Version 3, 12-Dec-88, mailed 12 Dec 88
	(some "bugs" in the proposal)
YES

UNREAD-CHAR-AFTER-PEEK-CHAR:DONT-ALLOW
	Version 2, 2-Dec-88, mailed 12-Dec-88
YES

VARIABLE-LIST-ASYMMETRY:SYMMETRIZE
	Version 3, 08-Oct-88, mailed 9 Dec 88
YES